I'm not completely against reboots and remakes. There are some
properties that deserve a second chance. One of them is Judge Dredd, who first
appeared in the long running British comic book anthology, 2000AD. The series was set in a dystopian future under the
totalitarian rule of the Judges, reflecting the prevailing mood amidst the
height of Thatcherism. Dredd himself was a grim and unquestioning servant of
the Judge System. He never removed his helmet, owing to his nature as a faceless
representation of the law. The 1995 feature film was undone the moment
Sylvester Stallone took off the helmet. He ceased to be Judge Dredd and was
merely Stallone ("I ahm da law.").
Released under the auspices of Disney's Touchstone banner, Judge Dredd ground the property through
the Hollywood machine and churned out a formulaic actioner full of cliches.
Gone were the violence and the political commentary, replaced by comic relief
sidekicks, romantic interests, and a hammy as hell Armand Assante. In the rich oeuvre of the Italian Stallion, it's no Demolition Man. At least,
the production values were high. Judge
Dredd did feature strong practical effects, marvelous set designs, and gaudy
costumes designed by Gianni Versace. The new Dredd isn't nearly as flashy.
Dredd is set in a dystopian future where the most of the world has been rendered uninhabitable by nuclear war. The survivors of this Cursed Earth live
in massive city-states, including Mega City One, located on the Eastern
Seaboard. The megalopolis stretches from Boston to Washington D.C. and is
policed by an overwhelmed force of Judges with the most infamous being the
Judge known as Dredd (Karl Urban). Dredd is paired with a rookie named
Cassandra Anderson (Olivia Thirlby), who has flunked the battery of tests required to
be a Street Judge. But, her potent psychic powers, a result of the surrounding
radiation, make her an invaluable asset.
Dredd and Anderson respond to a triple homicide at the 200-story
tall Peach Trees housing complex and arrest a small-time drug dealer named Kay
(Wood Harris). Kay is simply a cog in the machine of Madeline "Ma-Ma"
Madrigal (Lena Headey), a scarred crime lord manufacturing a designer drug
known as Slo-Mo, which allows the brain to experience reality at 1% speed.
Ma-Ma locks the entire building down and unleashes all her minions to kill the
Judges.
On the surface, the story of Dredd
bares a remarkable resemblance to The
Raid: Redemption, one of the best action movies in recent years. However, Dredd doesn't match up to the fight
sequences of The Raid. In fact, Dredd tends to get repetitive with one
shootout after another and multiple bodies being thrown off high ledges.
Director Pete Travis (Vantage Point)
does bring a visual flair to the proceedings with help from Oscar-winning
cinematographer Anthony Dod Mantle (Slumdog Millionaire). For once, there is a logical reason for the inclusion of slow
motion shot at 2500fps on the digital Phantom Flex camera. The slow motion is
stunning and highlighted by a saturated color palette. The 3D effects are well
done with shattered glass and splattered blood drifting out of the frame
towards the viewer. They aren't enough to justify the extra cost of a 3D
ticket, but you won't feel completely ripped off. The filmmakers have adapted
the look of Dredd into a grittier
world rooted in reality. Mega City One is a sprawling landscape of urban decay reminiscent
of Children of Men and District 9. The uniforms of the Judges are
bulkier and more militaristic in nature. And it wouldn't be Judge Dredd without the presence of the Judges' standard issue Lawgiver, a sidearm with biometric safeguards and programmable ammunition.
Screenwriter Alex Garland is known for crafting smart sci-fi
flicks with 28 Days Later, Sunshine, and Never Let Me Go on his resume. At one point, he wrote the script
for a Halo picture that came to
fruition. Dredd isn't exactly as
thought-provoking, but it remains faithful to the source material while working
within the limitations of a mid-range budget ($45 million). Dredd doesn't delve deeply into the
mythology of the comics. Instead, it serves as an introduction while following
the formula of a cop drama ala Training
Day. The film's measly opening weekend take of $6.3 million may have put
the kibosh on Garland's proposed sequels that would have involved more
ambitious elements, such as the Cursed Earth and Judge Death, a malevolent
being that deemed life as the ultimate crime. A few Easter eggs have been
thrown in to please the hardcore fans, including references to Fergee Memorial
Park and Chopper the graffiti artist.
The character of Judge Dredd is a difficult one to pull off
properly. He is unyielding authority, not a character that
goes through a lot of introspective soul searching. Thankfully, Garland never
attempts to humanize Dredd. Karl Urban plays the character to a tee, despite
having his face obscured by Dredd's trademark helmet. Urban gives him a gruff
and gravelly voice without going over-the-top in a Christian Bale sort of way.
The film's requisite emotional arc is imparted on Psi-Judge Anderson, who sees
the world in shades of gray in contrast to Dredd's myopic, black and white view.
Olivia Thirlby is an unlikely candidate to co-star in an action pic, but she
ably embodies the heart of the movie. Well, as much heart as a movie where
people are skinned alive can allow. Lena Headey is also good as Ma-Ma, a rare
instance in which the lead villain is female, though you wish she could have
been given more to do.
In terms of comic book franchise reboots, Dredd isn't Batman Begins.
It's more like Punisher: War Zone, a
stylishly violent improvement that doesn’t fully realize the potential of its
property.
Rating: *** (*****)